If a Defect Occurs During Construction, Is It an "Occurrence?"
February 12, 2024 —
Brendan J. Witry - The Dispute ResolverEstablishing insurance coverage for construction defects is almost as important as establishing liability in the underlying construction defect litigation itself.
The risk to the defendant contractor of defending a construction claim can place significant burdens on a contractor’s operations and an uninsured judgment might even put the contractor out of business.
For owners, suing a contractor for construction defects can become academic if there is no prospect of insurance coverage; obtaining a $1 million judgment against a contractor with limited assets would be a pyrrhic victory.
Commercial General Liability (CGL) carriers are obligated to defend claims that potentially fall within the coverage granted by the policy.[1] When presented with a claim, CGL insurers typically have three options: (1) assume the defense without reservation; (2) assume the defense asserting defenses to coverage, and depending on the state, reserving the right to recover defense costs if it later determines there is no duty to defend; or (3) deny the claim outright and seek a declaratory judgment holding that the insurer has no duty to defend or indemnify. An insurer may deny the claim outright and not seek a declaratory judgment, but does so at its peril because it can expose the insurer to significant liability if the insured later shows the insurer in fact had a duty to defend.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Brendan J. Witry, Laurie & Brennan LLPMr. Witry may be contacted at
bwitry@lauriebrennan.com
Products Liability Law – Application of Economic Loss Rule
April 02, 2024 —
David Adelstein - Florida Construction Legal UpdatesWhen it comes to product liability law, one important doctrine that will always come up is the economic loss rule. The economic loss rule, oftentimes going by its acronym ELR, lives and breathes in the realm of product liability law.
Does the economic loss rule extend to a manufacturer’s distributor for a duty to warn when the product is NOT defective? A recent opinion out of the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, NBIS Construction & Transport Ins. Services v. Liebherr-America, Inc., 2024 WL 861257 (11th Cir. 2024), was confronted with this question, including whether the economic loss rule should even extend to a distributor of a product, and certified the following to Florida’s Supreme Court to answer: “Whether, under Florida law, the economic loss rule applies to negligence claims against a distributor of a product, stipulated to be non-defective, for the failureto alert a product owner of a known danger, when the only damages claimed are to the product itself?” NBIS, supra, at *8.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
David Adelstein, Kirwin Norris, P.A.Mr. Adelstein may be contacted at
dma@kirwinnorris.com
Courts Will Not Second-Guess Public Entities When it Comes to Design Immunity
May 13, 2024 —
Garret Murai - California Construction Law BlogIt was a bizarre confluence of events. Jorgen Stufkosky was driving on SR-154 in Santa Ynez, California. Martha Aguayo was driving on the same highway ahead of Stufkosky when she struck a deer causing it to fly across the centerline into traffic from the opposite direction. The deer struck a SUV causing its driver to lose control. The driver of the SUV crossed the same centerline where he collided head on with Stufkosky, killing him.
Stufkosky’s children later sued the California Department of Transportation in the case Stufkosky v. California Department of Transportation, 97 Cal.App.5th 492 (2023), alleging that their father’s death was due to Caltrans’ negligent design of SR-153, inadequate number of deer crossing signs, and its high posted speed limit.
While in the trial court, Caltrans filed a motion for summary judgment on the ground that Caltrans was immune from liability under Government Code section 830.6, the so called “design immunity” statute.
The trial court agreed and the Stufloskys appealed.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Garret Murai, Nomos LLPMr. Murai may be contacted at
gmurai@nomosllp.com
Revolutionizing Buildings with Hybrid Energy Systems and Demand Response
January 08, 2024 —
Aarni Heiskanen - AEC BusinessA recent study conducted by the Finnish Building Services 2030 group explores the potential technologies and business prospects for adaptable energy systems within buildings.
Building Services 2030 is a Finnish consortium of Aalto University, Tampere University, and 14 industry partners. The consortium has defined a shared vision for the Finnish building service sector and researches topics that help reach the vision. My company is responsible for the group’s communication, so I eagerly read the research reports as they come out.
One of the new reports I found very timely is about the energy flexibility of buildings. The authors are Senior Researcher Juha Jokisalo and Professor Matti Lehtonen from Aalto University. They highlight how the contemporary energy landscape is undergoing a significant transformation.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Aarni Heiskanen, AEC BusinessMr. Heiskanen may be contacted at
aec-business@aepartners.fi
Empowering Success: The Advantages of Female Attorneys in Construction Defect Law
December 11, 2023 —
Alexa Stephenson, Hoosai Kabiri & Ivette Kincaid - Kahana FeldPer the most recent U.S. Census records, women make up 50.4% of the U.S. population. It should come as no surprise then that women currently outnumber men in U.S. law schools. Nevertheless, as of 2022, only 38% of attorneys, 30% of federal judges, 22% of equity partners, and 12% of managing partners nationwide are comprised of women. While great strides have been made in the last century to increase gender equality in the legal field, there is undoubtedly still a long way to go.
Studies have shown that women in the workforce lead to a number of benefits not only to the business itself, but to a business’ employees and culture. In the realm of construction defect law in particular, the presence and contributions of female attorneys have become increasingly impactful and essential. As the legal landscape evolves, the benefits of having female attorneys practicing in this specialized field are becoming more evident, offering a range of advantages that contribute to a more diverse, comprehensive, and successful legal environment. These advantages include:
1. Diverse Perspectives: Female attorneys bring a unique perspective to the practice of construction defect law, enriching the field with their insights and experiences. Their diverse backgrounds and viewpoints can lead to innovative strategies and fresh approaches when tackling complex legal issues.
Reprinted courtesy of
Alexa Stephenson, Kahana Feld,
Hoosai Kabiri, Kahana Feld and
Ivette Kincaid, Kahana Feld
Ms. Stephenson may be contacted at astephenson@kahanafeld.com
Ms. Kabiri may be contacted at hkabiri@kahanafeld.com
Ms. Kincaid may be contacted at ikincaid@kahanafeld.com
Read the full story...
Washington Court Denies Subcontractor’s Claim Based on Contractual Change and Notice Provisions
January 29, 2024 —
Wendy Rosenstein - Ahlers Cressman & Sleight PLLCThe recent unpublished case, Cascade Civil Construction, LLC v. Jackson Dean Construction, Inc., et al.,[1] provides a legal justification for contractors to require a directive or change order in advance of performing changed work—thereby preventing the party who requested the changed work from later arguing that notice provisions were not complied with.
In the case, Jackson Dean, the prime contractor, hired Cascade to perform excavation work on a project to build a new Costco Corporate headquarters. Due to the Covid-19 pandemic and other issues, Jackson Dean directed resequencing, which required Cascade to perform excavation concurrent to dewatering. Jackson Dean also required deeper-than-planned excavation under one of the buildings.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Wendy Rosenstein, Ahlers Cressman & Sleight PLLCMs. Rosenstein may be contacted at
wendy.rosenstein@acslawyers.com
Certificates of Merit: Is Your Texas Certificate Sufficient?
January 22, 2024 —
Gus Sara - The Subrogation StrategistIn Eric L. Davis Eng’g, Inc. v. Hegemeyer, No. 14-22-00657-CV, 2023 Tex. App. LEXIS 8899, the Court of Appeals of Texas (Court of Appeals) considered whether the plaintiffs’ certificate of merit, in support of their professional malpractice claim against the defendant engineers, adequately set forth the experience and qualifications of the expert who submitted the certificate. The defendants filed a motion to dismiss, alleging that the certificate of merit was inadequate because it failed to establish that the expert practiced in the same specific areas as the defendants in relation to the work at issue. The lower court denied the defendants’ motion. The Court of Appeals affirmed the lower court’s decision, finding that there was sufficient information for the lower court to have reasonably found that the plaintiffs’ expert practiced in the same area as the defendants.
In Hegemeyer, the plaintiffs sued Eric L. Davis Engineering, Inc. (Davis) and Kenneth L. Douglass (Douglass
New Pedestrian, Utility Bridge Takes Shape on Everett WaterfrontMaking Construction Innovation StickTraub Lieberman Partner Stephen Straus Wins Spoliation Motion in Favor of DefendantDifference Between a Novation And A Modification to a ContractHunton Insurance Partner, Larry Bracken, Elected to the American College of Coverage CounselFailure to Comply with Sprinkler Endorsement Bars Coverage for Fire DamageInsured's Failure to Challenge Trial Court's Application of Exclusion Makes Appeal FutileImpaired Property Exclusion Bars Coverage When Loose Bolt Interferes with MRI Unit OperationDistressed Home Sales ShrinkingContractor’s Claim for Interest on Subcontractor’s Defective Work Claim Gains Mixed ResultsNo Additional Insured Coverage Under Umbrella PolicyReal Estate & Construction News Round-Up (11/02/22) – Flexible Workspaces, Sustainable Infrastructure, & Construction TechFlow-Down Clauses Can Drown Your ProjectNo Coverage For Wind And Flood Damage Suffered From Superstorm SandyEvent-Cancellation Insurance Issues During a PandemicAssociation Bound by Arbitration Provision in Purchase-And-Sale Contracts and DeedsWhen Is a Project Delay Material and Actionable?Drug Company Provides Cure for Development WoesHouse of Digital TwinsCondo Board Goes after Insurer for Construction Defect SettlementCOVID-19 Likely No Longer Covered Under Force MajeureConstruction Defect Leads to Death, Jury Awards $39 MillionAugust Home Prices in 20 U.S. Cities Appreciate at
Florida Governor Bans Foreign Citizens From Buying Land in Florida
Builder Waits too Long to Dispute Contract in Construction Defect Claim
New Certification Requirements for Veteran-Owned Small Business Concerns and Service-Disabled Veteran-owned Small Business Concerns Seeking Public Procurement Contracts
How SmartThings Wants to Automate Your Home
House of the Week: Spanish Dream Home on California's Riviera
New York’s 2022 Comprehensive Insurance Disclosure Act: Significant Amendments to the C.P.L.R.
"Decay" Found Ambiguous in Collapse Case
Construction Defects Not Occurrences under Ohio Law
Canada Housing Starts Increase on Multiple-Unit Projects
That Boilerplate Language May Just Land You in Hot Water
The Ups and Downs of Elevator Maintenance Contractor's Policy Limits
Plaintiff’s Mere Presence in Area Where Asbestos is Present Insufficient to Establish Bystander Exposure
Insurer's Attempt to Limit Additional Insured Status Fails
Insureds Survive Summary Judgment on Coverage for Hurricane Loss
UK Agency Seeks Stricter Punishments for Illegal Wastewater Discharges
Zombie Foreclosures Plaguing Various Cities in the U.S.
Famed NYC Bridge’s Armor Is Focus of Suit Against French Company
Georgia Super Lawyers Recognized Two Lawyers from Hunton’s Insurance Recovery Group
New York Court Rejects Owner’s Bid for Additional Insured Coverage
If You Purchase a House at an HOA Lien Foreclosure, Are You Entitled to Excess Sale Proceeds?
Beyond the COI: The Importance of an Owner's or Facilities Manager's Downstream Insurance Review Program
A Court-Side Seat: SCOTUS Clarifies Alien Tort Statute and WOTUS Is Revisited
Wendel Rosen’s Construction Practice Group Receives First Tier Ranking
Construction Defect or Just Punch List?
Brief Discussion of Enforceability of Anti-Indemnity Statutes in California
Wilke Fleury Attorneys Awarded Sacramento Business Journal’s Best of the Bar
Maximizing Contractual Indemnity Rights: Insuring the Indemnitor's Obligation
California Supreme Court Rules Developers can be Required to Include Affordable Housing
Blue-Sky Floods Take a Rising Toll for Businesses
COVID-19 Response: Recent Executive Orders Present Opportunities for Businesses Seeking Regulatory and Enforcement Relief and Expedited Project Development
Heavy Rains Cause Flooding, Mudslides in Japan
White and Williams Ranked in Top Tiers of "Best Law Firms"
After $15 Million Settlement, Association Gets $7.7 Million From Additional Subcontractor
NJ Condo Construction Defect Case Dismissed over Statute of Limitations
Condo Owners Suing Bank for Failing to Disclose Defects
Buy Clean California Act Takes Effect on July 1, 2022
Why’d You Have To Say That?
Mexico’s Construction Industry Posts First Expansion Since 2012
Amos Rex – A Museum for the Digital Age
New Home Permits Surge in Wisconsin
Purse Tycoon Aims at Ultra-Rich With $85 Million Home
Pennsylvania Court Finds that Two Possible Causes Can Prove a Product Malfunction Theory of Liability
Eleventh Circuit Holds that EPA Superfund Remedial Actions are Usually Entitled to the FTCA “Discretionary Function” Exemption
It’s All a Matter of [Statutory] Construction: Supreme Court Narrowly Interprets the Good Faith Dispute Exception to Prompt Payment Requirements in United Riggers & Erectors, Inc. v. Coast Iron & Steel Co.
Judgment Stemming from a Section 998 Offer Without a Written Acceptance Provision Is Void
Strict Rules for Home Remodel Contracts in California
Endorsements Do Not Exclude Coverage for Wrongful Death Claim
Floating Cities May Be One Answer to Rising Sea Levels
Statutory Time Limits for Construction Defects in Massachusetts
With Vice President's Tie-Breaker, US Senate Approves Far-Reaching Climate Bill
