Enforceability of Contract Provisions Extending Liquidated Damages Beyond Substantial Completion
April 15, 2024 —
Stu Richeson - The Dispute ResolverThis post takes a look at the enforceability of contract provisions providing for liquidated delay damages after substantial completion. Typically, the assessment of liquidated delay damages ends at substantial completion of a project. However, various standard form contracts, including some of the ConsensusDocs and EJCDC contracts, contain elections allowing for the parties to agree on the use of liquidated damages for failing to achieve substantial completion, final completion, or project milestones. The standard language in the AIA A201 leaves it up to the parties to define the circumstances under which liquidated damages will be awarded.
Courts are split on the enforceability of provisions that seek to assess liquidated damages beyond substantial completions. Courts in some jurisdictions will not impose liquidated damages after the date of substantial completion on the ground that liquidated damages would otherwise become a penalty if assessed after the owner has put the project to its intended use. Perini Corp. v. Greate Bay Hotel & Casino, Inc., 129 N.J. 479, 610 A.2d 364 (1992). When the terms are clear, other jurisdictions will enforce contract terms providing for liquidated damages until final completion, even if the owner has taken beneficial use of the facility. Carrothers Const. Co. v. City of S. Hutchinson, 288 Kan. 743, 207 P.3d 231 (2009).
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Stu Richeson, PhelpsMr. Richeson may be contacted at
stuart.richeson@phelps.com
Environmental Justice Update: The Justice40 Initiative
April 29, 2024 —
Anthony B. Cavender - Gravel2Gavel Construction & Real Estate Law BlogSoon after taking office, President Biden issued Executive Order 14008, entitled, “Tackling the Climate Crisis at Home and Abroad.” This is an unusually long and complex executive order and includes many provisions relating to environmental justice and the plight of “disadvantaged communities” that are overwhelmed by many environmental threats. Section 223 of the Order describes the President’s “Justice40 Initiative,” which is designed to ensure that 40% of Federal benefits flow to disadvantaged communities through an “all of government approach.” There is a recognition that some disadvantaged communities lack the personnel and resources to take advantage of this Initiative, so technical training funds will be made available. The Order establishes new offices throughout the Federal bureaucracy to handle and expedite environmental justice matters.
The Office of Management and Budget (OMB) and the Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) play a large role in implementing the Initiative by issuing appropriate guidance and assisting the Federal agencies to locate, among the thousands of programs they supervise, suitable programs that will assist disadvantaged communities. At last count, 518 Federal programs administered by 19 distinct Federal agencies could be a good source for the resources needed by disadvantaged communities to cope with air and water pollution and solid waste issues. Direct grants will be made in many cases, and other programs require the community to apply for the funds promised by the Executive Order. In addition, the Order requires participating Federal agencies to assess the value and effectiveness of the benefits bestowed. OMB and the CEQ have issued guidance documents and conducted many meetings with key personnel and members of the disadvantaged communities.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Anthony B. Cavender, PillsburyMr. Cavender may be contacted at
anthony.cavender@pillsburylaw.com
Saving Manhattan: Agencies, Consultants, Contractors Join Fight to Keep New York City Above Water
November 27, 2023 —
Pam McFarland & Corinne Grinapol - Engineering News-RecordIn densely populated cities surrounded on all sides by water—the borough of Manhattan in New York City as a prime example—the risks from sea level rise and climate change are not just hypotheticals; they are existential threats.
Reprinted courtesy of
Pam McFarland, Engineering News-Record and
Corinne Grinapol, Engineering News-Record
Ms. McFarland may be contacted at mcfarlandp@enr.com
Read the full story...
ASCE Releases New Report on Benefits and Burdens of Infrastructure Investment in Disadvantaged Communities
February 05, 2024 —
The American Society of Civil EngineersWashington — The
American Society of Civil Engineers today released a new paper, Measuring the Benefits and Burdens of Infrastructure in Disadvantaged Communities. The report looks at how several communities across the country consider equity when investing infrastructure funds, and the impact of those projects on lower-income communities.
"Civil engineers are focused on improving quality of life by building systems that improve the public's health, safety, and well-being," said Marsia Geldert-Murphey, P.E., 2024 President, ASCE. "However, the decisions on how and where infrastructure is built can affect communities for decades after a project is complete. By looking at the benefits and burdens of past projects, infrastructure owners and developers can find better ways to consider the impact of infrastructure projects being designed now."
Some of the recommendations in the paper include encouraging government and other infrastructure stakeholders to use community engagement and transparent metrics when making decisions about proposed infrastructure investments. It also encourages post-project assessments and the use of existing resources to evaluate the positive and unexpected consequences of past infrastructure projects.
Measuring the Benefits and Burdens of Infrastructure in Disadvantaged Communities is
available here.
ABOUT THE AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CIVIL ENGINEERS
Founded in 1852, the American Society of Civil Engineers represents more than 150,000 civil engineers worldwide and is America's oldest national engineering society. ASCE works to raise awareness of the need to maintain and modernize the nation's infrastructure using sustainable and resilient practices, advocates for increasing and optimizing investment in infrastructure, and improve engineering knowledge and competency. For more information, visit www.asce.org or www.infrastructurereportcard.org and follow us on Twitter, @ASCETweets and @ASCEGovRel.
Real Estate & Construction News Roundup (10/04/23) – NFL Star Gets into Real Estate, DOJ Focuses on “Buyer-Broker Commissions”, and the Auto Workers’ Strike Continues
November 13, 2023 —
Pillsbury's Construction & Real Estate Law Team - Gravel2Gavel Construction & Real Estate Law BlogIn our latest roundup, seller impersonation fraud becomes an issue in the United States, major retailers are closing over 3,000 stores nationwide, the Tampa Rays are set to construct a new $1.3 billion stadium, and more!
- NFL star Tyler Lockett is preparing for his life and career after football by becoming a real estate broker in both Washington state and Texas. (Brady Henderson, ESPN)
- Seller impersonation fraud has become a major scam in the United States with 73% of real estate firms reporting an increase in these schemes since the beginning of the year. (Diane Tomb, Fortune)
- “Buyer-broker commissions” are a focus for the U.S. Justice Department as they have filed a “statement of interest” in one case in Massachusetts while there are several other pending lawsuits in U.S. courts. (Mike Scarcella, Reuters)
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Pillsbury's Construction & Real Estate Law Team
Expanded Virginia Court of Appeals Leads to Policyholder Relief
January 29, 2024 —
Michael S. Levine & Olivia G. Bushman - Hunton Insurance Recovery BlogExercising its newly expanded jurisdiction that now permits Virginia’s intermediate appellate courts to hear insurance coverage disputes, the Court of Appeals recently reversed a lower court decision that allowed a two-year “Suits Against Us” provision to serve as a basis for an insurer’s refusal to reimburse repair and replacement costs incurred more than two years after the date of loss. Bowman II v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co., Record No. 1256-22-3 (Nov. 21, 2023). CAV (unpublished opinion).
In the proceeding below, the circuit court found no justiciable controversy and dismissed the complaint where repairs to the policyholder’s fire-damaged home continued more than two years after the date of the fire. The circuit court relied on a two-year limitation in the policy that governed the period within which the policyholder must bring suit against the insurer.
Reprinted courtesy of
Michael S. Levine, Hunton Andrews Kurth and
Olivia G. Bushman, Hunton Andrews Kurth
Mr. Levine may be contacted at mlevine@HuntonAK.com
Ms. Bushman may be contacted at obushman@HuntonAK.com
Read the full story...
Higgins, Hopkins, McLain & Roswell Recognized in 2024 Best Law Firm® Rankings
November 16, 2023 —
David M. McLain – Colorado Construction Litigation BlogWe are thrilled to announce that Higgins, Hopkins, McLain & Roswell, LLC (“HHMR”) has been recognized in the 2024 Best Law Firm® rankings. Our firm has been placed in Metro Tier 2 in Colorado for Construction Law, a testament to our unwavering commitment to providing top-tier legal services.
At HHMR, we pride ourselves on our expertise in construction law and the litigation of construction-related claims. Our team of dedicated attorneys is well-versed and experienced in tort, contract, property, and general casualty litigation. This recognition by Best Lawyers affirms our dedication to serving our clients selflessly and to the best of our ability.
Will Claims By Contractors on Big Design-Build Projects Ever End?Proposed Law Protecting Tenants Amended: AB 828 UpdatedConstruction Defect Class Action Lawsuit Alleges National Cover-up of Pipe DefectsCalifornia Supreme Court Allows Claim Under Unfair Competition Statute To ProceedWhat is the True Value of Rooftop Solar Panels?Excess Carrier's Declaratory Judgment Action Stayed While Underlying Case Still PendingWest Coast Casualty’s 25th Construction Defect Seminar Has BegunKentucky Supreme Court Creates New “Goldilocks Zone” to Limit Opinions of Biomechanical ExpertsMortgage Firms Face Foreclosure Ban Until 2022 Under CFPB PlanOne-Upmanship by Contractors In Prevailing Wage Decision Leads to a Bad Result for All . . . PerhapsCan’t Get a Written Change Order? Document, Document, DocumentPayne & Fears LLP Recognized by U.S. News & World Report and Best Lawyers in 2023 “Best Law Firms” RankingsTexas EIFS Case May Have Future Implications for Construction DefectsNevada Supr
Need to Cover Yourself for “Crisis” Changes on a Job Site? Try These Tips (guest post)
New York’s Comprehensive Insurance Disclosure Act Imposes Increased Disclosure Requirements On Defendants at the Beginning of Lawsuits
Potential Problems with Cases Involving One Owner and Multiple Contractors
California’s High Speed Rail Project. Are We Done With the Drama?
Design-Assist Collaboration/Follow-up Post
California Joins the Majority of States in Modifying Its Survival Action Statute To Now Permit Recovery for Pain, Suffering And Disfigurement
Building the Secondary Market for Reclaimed Building Materials
What is an Alternative Dispute Resolution?
A Subcontractor’s Perspective On California’s Recent Changes to Indemnity Provisions
Contract Provisions That Help Manage Risk on Long-Term Projects
Cuba: Construction Boom Potential for U.S. Construction Companies and Equipment Manufacturers?
New Opportunities for “Small” Construction Contractors as SBA Adjusts Its Size Standards Again Due to Unprecedented Inflation
No Coverage for Faulty Workmanship Causing Property Damage to Insured's Product Only
COVID-19 Response: Key Legal Considerations for Event Cancellations
Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court Clarifies Pennsylvania’s Strict Liability Standard
Will Superusers Future-Proof the AEC Industry?
Claims Litigated Under Government Claims Act Must “Fairly Reflect” Factual Claims Made in Underlying Government Claim
EEOC Sues Schuff Steel, J.A. Croson in New Racial Harassment Cases
Adaptive Reuse: Creative Reimagining of Former Office Space to Address Differing Demands
New Jersey Court Upholds Registration Requirement for Joint Ventures Bidding on Public Works Contracts
Newmeyer & Dillion Attorneys Listed in the Best Lawyers in America© 2017
Congress Passes, President Signs Sweeping Energy Measure In Spend Bill
Montana Court Finds Duty to Defend over Construction Defect Allegation
Insurer Must Defend Additional Insured Though Its Insured is a Non-Party
Blackstone Said in $1.7 Billion Deal to Buy Apartments
Colorado Court of Appeals Decides the Triple Crown Case
How BIM Can Serve Building Owners
Pollution Exclusion Does Not Apply To Concrete Settling Dust
What Buyers Want in a Green Home—and What They Don’t
URGENT: 'Catching Some Hell': Hurricane Michael Slams Into Florida
Navigating Threshold Arbitration Issues in Construction Contracts
New York’s Second Department Holds That Carrier Must Pay Judgment Obtained by Plaintiff as Carrier Did Not Meet Burden to Prove Willful Non-Cooperation
Storm Breaches California River's Levee, Thousands Evacuate
EPA and the Corps of Engineers Repeal the 2015 “Waters of the United States” Rule
New York Court of Appeals Finds a Proximate Cause Standard in Additional Insured Endorsements
Tips for Drafting Construction Contracts
Illinois Legislature Enables Pre-Judgment Interest in Personal Injury Cases
Ohio Court Refuses to Annualize Multi-Year Policies’ Per Occurrence Limits
When Does a Claim Against an Insurance Carrier for Failing to Defend Accrue?
California Supreme Court Protects California Policyholders for Intentional Acts of Employees
Allegations Versus “True Facts”: Which Govern the Duty to Defend? Bonus! A Georgia Court Clears Up What the Meaning of “Is” Is
Beyond the Disneyland Resort: Special Events
After Fatal House Explosion, Colorado Seeks New Pipeline Regulations
Appraisal Can Go Forward Prior to Resolution of Coverage Dispute
Is Ohio’s Buckeye Lake Dam Safe?
Substantial Completion Explained: What Contractors & Owners Should Know
CGL Policy May Not Cover Cybersecurity and Data-Related Losses
Skanska Found Negligent for Damages From Breakaway Barges
Congratulations 2016 DE, NJ, and PA Super Lawyers and Rising Stars
Insurers Can Sue One Another for Defense Costs on Equitable Indemnity and Equitable Contribution Basis
